Denver Post Broncos beat writer Parker Gabriel posts his Broncos Mailbag weekly during the season and periodically during the offseason. Click here to submit a question.
Besides quarterback, what other positions will the Broncos need to address during the offseason? And will Sean Payton try to fill critical needs via free agency or the draft?
— Ed Helinski, Auburn, N.Y.
Hey Ed, thanks for writing in and getting us going this week.
Quarterback is going to dominate the conversation this offseason, but the Broncos’ list of needs is long. That’s complicated by the fact that Denver has only six draft picks at present. Not only that, but check out this quote from GM George Paton during Tuesday’s season wrap-up interviews:
“We won’t be in on the first wave of free agency like we were last year,” he said. “You can’t do that every year. We’ll be very strategic and very specific on what positions and what players we try to sign. Obviously, we have to hit on the draft. We’re picking high, and we have six picks. We could have more. You know we like picks. We’ll go from there.”
CEO Greg Penner shared the same sentiment about spending big in free agency last spring, but it hits home even a little extra with the Russell Wilson contract situation playing out and the likelihood that Denver will be dealing with the fallout of that for the next two seasons.
Just as a starting point: Aside from quarterback, the Broncos would be justified in using their first-round pick at offensive tackle, edge, interior defensive line, cornerback or receiver.
Their free-agent list includes starting center Lloyd Cushenberry, starting inside linebacker Josey Jewell, two tight ends in Adam Trautman and Chris Manhertz, starting safety P.J. Locke, fullback Mike Burton, cornerback Fabian Moreau and kicker Wil Lutz. We’re not talking blue-chip players, but that is a ton of snaps from a wide variety of positions.
Both free agency and the draft will be critical, but right now Denver’s walking a little bit of a tightrope to get everything done.
I have watched Bo Nix up close, and believe he will be a solid pro. He is a leader, smart, a student of the game, an accurate passer, and sufficiently mobile. He could be Sean Payton’s new Drew Brees. He could very well be available when the Broncos select in the draft. He would be worth trading up a place or two to get. Your thoughts?
— Kenny, Lake Oswego, Ore.
Hey Kenny, yeah you’ve had a front seat for the Nix Show up there in the Pacific Northwest. He really took off after transferring from Auburn to Oregon.
I haven’t done a deep dive on the quarterback class yet, so I don’t have any super hot takes at the moment. I do think that after the top group — even if we put LSU’s Jayden Daniels in along with USC’s Caleb Williams and North Carolina’s Drake Maye as likely top picks — you get into the area where you’re talking tradeoffs. For Michael Penix Jr., it’s risk tolerance on the injury front and how his medicals look at the NFL Scouting Combine. For J.J. McCarthy, it’s youth and the lack of big passing production on a dominant rushing team. For Nix, it’s six years in college and questions about arm strength.
Teams line up for quarterbacks, so even if you don’t have a true first-round grade on a guy, that doesn’t mean he will last until the second or third. I’d be leery of moving up for anybody besides one of the top picks because of the other needs outlined above. But if Payton and Paton feel strongly about somebody, they’ll consider going to get him. No doubt about it.
Should the Broncos go shopping for a new head coach?
— Rosanne, Littleton
Hey Rosanne, it wasn’t all sunshine and rainbows with Payton this year, but A) that’s not going to happen and B) constant turnover is part of the problem in Denver, not the solution.
That doesn’t mean that Payton won’t be held to a high standard going forward. Payton’s got to win, just like anybody else, and when you have his resume and salary, there’s not going to be a multiyear grace period.
Related note: The coaching carousel in the NFL is already wild this year. Jim Harbaugh might actually make the jump after flirting with the Broncos last winter. Seattle’s Pete Carroll is out in a shocking move. Tennessee fired Mike Vrabel. The Patriots could move off of Bill Belichick, perhaps via trade. Buckle up.
It appears that it doesn’t matter who the QB is. The Broncos called the same lousy plays for Jarrett Stidham as they did for Russell Wilson. The only creative offensive play was the pass to Jerry Jeudy as he made a slant cut across the field from left to right. Does the OC prepare the game plan or is that Sean Payton’s bit of non-brilliance?
— MaryLou Fenili, Denver
Hey MaryLou, thanks for the question! The game-planning process is collaborative between Payton, offensive coordinator Joe Lombardi, passing game coordinator John Morton and many others. But the bottom line is it’s Payton’s plan, Payton’s play-sheet and Payton dialing up the calls during games.
So, if there’s a bone to pick with the plan or the calls, it’s with the head coach.
Don’t you feel George Paton should go? He mortgaged away all draft picks, gave a washed-up quarterback a gigantoid contract before stepping foot on field. He’s totally inept and set the organization back light years. How do we recover from this?
— JJF, Woodland Park
JJF, appreciate the question. Not really my place to say should or shouldn’t in this case, but clearly Paton’s missed big on the highest-profile decisions he’s made, including trading for Wilson and hiring Nathaniel Hackett. The Randy Gregory signing was bad, too, though picking Pat Surtain II at No. 9 in 2021 was really good.
Track record and performance matter. Paton would tell you that, too. The reality at this moment, though, is that Paton and Payton say they work well together, and Penner thinks the partnership is set up for success going forward. They made that pretty clear Tuesday.
Hi Parker, this is my first time submitting but I feel strongly that the Broncos would be better off firing the two Paytons and keeping Russ. Paton is responsible for some of the worst GM moves in Broncos history, and Payton has not lived up to his expectations as a coach. It might not be cheap to get rid of the two of them, but it would cost less than dumping Russ (plus we would have next year’s QB). Do you think that is a possibility?
— Paul C. Duchateau, Fort Collins
Hey Paul, hadn’t come across this opinion yet, so thanks for writing! The short answer is that’s never going to happen. And I’d be curious how you square calling Paton responsible for some of the worst moves in Broncos history with saying that Wilson is who Denver should build around in the future.
You’re right about Paton and even Payton being cheaper to get rid of than Wilson, especially if you’re talking about roster building. Cash is cash — the Broncos have the wealthiest owners in North American sports — but the constraints in ditching Wilson come via salary cap accounting.
Hi Parker, Have you heard any news and/or rumors lately on when the new Broncos uniform will come out? I keep hearing (hoping) they’ll be released for the 2024 season! Also, any hints as to what they might look like?
Thanks for your time!
— Scott, Greeley
Hey Scott, thanks for writing in. Penner on Tuesday didn’t have a concrete update. The timeline all along has suggested that something could happen this offseason. So we’ll see. Not sure at this point if that’s something you unveil around the draft or maybe later in the summer/closer to camp. Probably depends some on the process, which is a long one.
Hi Parker, thanks for your coverage this season. I know the big thing in town is about the quarterback position, but what do you think about the Broncos taking a cornerback with their first-round pick? We need a more permanent solution at CB2. Damarri Mathis was certainly not it and Fabian Moreau is OK, but we could use an upgrade. What are your thoughts on taking either Kool-Aid McKinstry or Nate Wiggins at No. 12?
— Mike, Denver
Definitely, Mike. That’s a position the Broncos could address early in the draft. Another guy in that mix is, maybe not surprisingly, McKinstry’s Alabama teammate Terrion Arnold.
Moreau’s a free agent, so we’ll see what happens there. Mathis showed promise in 2022 and struggled this year. Don’t forget about Riley Moss, who got off to a slow start because of core muscle surgery during training camp but turned into one of Denver’s best special teams players as a rookie. He’s going to get a chance.
The Broncos liked Moss enough last spring to deal a 2024 third-round pick (New Orleans’, as it turns out) to move up from No. 109 to No. 83 to pick him.
Fast forward to present and that third-rounder they gave up projects as No. 81 overall in April.
Want more Broncos news? Sign up for the Broncos Insider to get all our NFL analysis.